What's so great about English education anyway? | The Daily Star
Skip to main content
E-paper বাংলা
T
Latest
Gavi dazzles as Barca beat Madrid to win Spanish Super Cup Mobile operators must pay their dues: BTRC chairman Chelsea earn scrappy 1-0 win over Palace to ease pressure BCB fines Salahuddin for criticism of umpiring Yearly Reports On Crashes: Secretary, transport leaders slam road safety campaigners EC enrols 79.83 lakh new voters 68 killed in Nepal plane crash Wasa terms report on MD’s 14 houses 'baseless' Ramsdale confirms altercation with Spurs fan after derby win Classy Arsenal outgun Spurs to extend lead at the top Properties In Dubai: Investigate allegations against 459 Bangladeshis Bangladesh should carry on reforms Egypt unveils ancient royal tomb in Luxor Tk 472cr embezzlement: HC blasts BPC for its inaction How did the Nepal plane crash happen?
The Daily Star
Journalism Without Fear or Favour
Monday, January 16, 2023
  • E-paper
  • বাংলা
Latest
Gavi dazzles as Barca beat Madrid to win Spanish Super Cup Mobile operators must pay their dues: BTRC chairman Chelsea earn scrappy 1-0 win over Palace to ease pressure BCB fines Salahuddin for criticism of umpiring Yearly Reports On Crashes: Secretary, transport leaders slam road safety campaigners EC enrols 79.83 lakh new voters 68 killed in Nepal plane crash Wasa terms report on MD’s 14 houses 'baseless' Ramsdale confirms altercation with Spurs fan after derby win Classy Arsenal outgun Spurs to extend lead at the top Properties In Dubai: Investigate allegations against 459 Bangladeshis Bangladesh should carry on reforms Egypt unveils ancient royal tomb in Luxor Tk 472cr embezzlement: HC blasts BPC for its inaction How did the Nepal plane crash happen?
The Daily Star
Monday, January 16, 2023 | Journalism Without Fear or Favour
  • Home
  • News
    • Bangladesh
    • Asia
    • World
  • Opinion
    • Views
    • Editorial
    • Letters to the Editor
  • Health
    • Diseases
    • Healthcare
    • Food
  • Sports
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • More Sports
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Global Economy
    • Organisation News
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Film
    • Music
    • Theatre & Arts
  • Culture
    • Art & Design
    • Books
  • Life & Living
    • Fashion & Beauty
    • Food & Recipes
    • Health & Fitness
  • Youth
    • Education
    • Careers
    • Young Icons
  • Tech & Startup
    • Science, Gadgets, and Tech
    • Startups
    • Automobiles
  • Feature
    • Lifestyle
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Showbiz
    • Star Health
    • Satireday
    • Shout
    • Toggle
    • Star Literature
    • In Focus
    • Star Youth
    • Law & Our Rights
    • Daily Star Books
    • Roundtables
    • Supplements
  • Environment
    • Climate crisis
    • Natural resources
    • Pollution
  • NRB
বাংলা T
  • Home
  • News
    • Bangladesh
    • Asia
    • World
  • Opinion
    • Views
    • Editorial
    • Letters to the Editor
  • Health
    • Diseases
    • Healthcare
    • Food
  • Sports
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • More Sports
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Global Economy
    • Organisation News
  • Entertainment
    • TV & Film
    • Music
    • Theatre & Arts
  • Culture
    • Art & Design
    • Books
  • Life & Living
    • Fashion & Beauty
    • Food & Recipes
    • Health & Fitness
  • Youth
    • Education
    • Careers
    • Young Icons
  • Tech & Startup
    • Science, Gadgets, and Tech
    • Startups
    • Automobiles
  • Feature
    • Lifestyle
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Showbiz
    • Star Health
    • Satireday
    • Shout
    • Toggle
    • Star Literature
    • In Focus
    • Star Youth
    • Law & Our Rights
    • Daily Star Books
    • Roundtables
    • Supplements
  • Environment
    • Climate crisis
    • Natural resources
    • Pollution
  • NRB

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • SMS Subscription
  • Apps
  • Comment Policy
  • RSS
  • Sitemap
  • Advertisement
  • Newsletter
  • Privacy Policy
  • Conference Hall
  • Archives
Views

What's so great about English education anyway?

Jasimuz Zaman, Matilal Pal
Thu Jan 12, 2023 12:00 AM Last update on: Thu Jan 12, 2023 12:29 AM
What's so great about English education anyway?
VISUAL: AFIA JAHIN

Despite remarkable economic growth in Bangladesh, the allocation for education in terms of percentage of GDP is low compared to most other countries in the region and globally. And one of the most overlooked problems is that we overspend on English education and under-spend on Bangla and STEM subjects.

There has rarely been any serious discussion about our education sector from an economic approach. What are the economic costs of English education? And what are its economic benefits? There is a pressing need to compare the two.

For all latest news, follow The Daily Star's Google News channel.

We have reasons to believe that neither the costs, nor the benefits, of English education are properly assessed. The benefits are also artificially exaggerated by a) the imposition of the English language by the colonists and the high status attributed to it by our own colonial mindset; b) the domination of the Urdu-speaking West Pakistan over the then East Pakistan and the relief from that sought by Bangladeshis by acquiring an English education; and c) the influence of a small but powerful elite/pseudo-elite group within Bangladesh propagating the importance of English.

‘New year, new curriculum’ cannot transform our school education

Read more

These factors have given way to the government's uncritical prescription and implementation of English as a compulsory subject from Classes 1 to 12. Globalisation has also created a strong perception that English and economic development are positively correlated.

The decision to implement Bangla at all levels of education was taken at a sentimental point in the history of our country. However, two things acted against the realisation of the objective of this decision: 1) the tumultuous situation in educational institutions resulting in a total lack of quality education and 2) the absence of any government programme to have textbooks and other related books translated or composed in Bangla.

By the time our education system gained some normalcy, a culture of mediocrity had come into being within the school system. In addition to a grave loss in the quality of education in general, a lamentable quality of English education became a matter of the greatest concern for the dominating social class. The intelligentsia, instead of looking for ways to circumvent the problem, started blaming the government for the decision of making Bangla mandatory.

This led to the proliferation of English-medium schools, leading to the commercialisation of education, foreign influence in the training of English teachers and a spread of specific pedagogical models. What is more tragic is that the government itself joined the bandwagon by introducing the English version of the Bangla curriculum. Middle-class parents, in their quest to achieve the perceived benefits of an English education, are rushing to any English version schools available.

Bangla: What is it good for?

Read more

Recently, research has shown that over-expenditure in English education has led to under-expenditure for other subjects, particularly Bangla and STEM subjects. At the same time, English education drains away a disproportionate amount of students' time.

The reality is that the entire mass of students does not need perfect English skills for their working life, let alone for life in general. The individual needs and aspirations of students should be the primary driving force to help them gain skills necessary for them.

The education system may focus on a minimum level of performance for all students in specific aspects of language learning, that is, vocabulary, spelling, pronunciation, listening, speaking, reading and writing.

Our experience and analysis with the implementation of an English Language Skill Enhancement Program in rural Bangladesh, as part of our work with an international NGO, gave us some insight into the needs and aspirations of common people vis-à-vis English education. The true demand for English does not exist in all sectors of Bangladesh's economy, but relates to specific sectors and sub-sectors. Hence, costs and benefits of an English education should be estimated in terms of "segmented" markets.

We have identified the various segmented markets for English in Bangladesh and the "level" of English required in these segments or the sub-sector of the education sector.

Building social cohesion: How can education help?

Read more

A "high" level of English education is required when teaching English (at secondary and tertiary levels); working in higher levels of the judiciary, in foreign services, for international assignments with international agencies and NGOs, and in Bangladeshi offices of multinational companies; working in the media; and training people for employment or studies in foreign countries.

A "medium" level of English education is required when working in administration or working as a primary school teacher. And finally, "specialised" training in English is required when becoming a specialist professional (in medicine, engineering, science, etc); working in the ICT sector; working in international trade and areas related to international supply chains, in tourism and hospitality industries; and working abroad – in skilled, semi-skilled, and unskilled jobs.

In our view, an economic cost-benefit analysis of English education will lead to the right amounts of expenditure in English, Bangla and STEM education. To this end, we recommend that the government creates an effective English curriculum to meet the basic needs of the population, leaving medium and high levels of skills outside the regular curriculum. Public and private sectors should also act together to collect and analyse data and information on the costs and benefits of acquiring an above-basic level of English education when working under different segments of the economy.

Matilal Pal is a former official of the Volunteers Association for Bangladesh (VAB). Jasimuz Zaman is former country director of Volunteers Association for Bangladesh (VAB).

Related topic
education Bangladesh / English Medium schools / english version / english education
Apple Google
Click to comment

Comments

Comments Policy

Related News

A photo of girls sitting together and reading a textbook
SHOUT

The bitter relationship between English version students and board exams

English medium schools
Weekend Read

English medium schools: When money matters most

Gender diversity in Bangladeshi trial textbook for seventh grade brings hope of change
9h ago| Views

Refreshing inclusion of gender diversity in trial textbook

Country

HC stops VAT on English medium students for 6 months

Opinion

The futility of the debate

The Daily Star  | বাংলা
৪৩ মিনিট আগে|দুর্ঘটনা ও অগ্নিকাণ্ড

গাইবান্ধায় বাস-ট্রাক-মোটরসাইকেল সংঘর্ষে নিহত ৩

গাইবান্ধার পলাশবাড়ি উপজেলায় বাস, ট্রাক ও মোটরসাইকেলের সংঘর্ষে ৩ জন নিহত হয়েছেন।

২ ঘণ্টা আগে|অর্থনীতি

আইএমএফ ঋণের প্রথম কিস্তি ফেব্রুয়ারিতে আসতে পারে

The Daily Star
Follow Us
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • SMS Subscription
  • Apps
  • Comment Policy
  • RSS
  • Sitemap
  • Advertisement
  • Newsletter
  • Privacy Policy
  • Conference Hall
  • Archives
© 2023 thedailystar.net | Powered by: RSI LAB
Copyright: Any unauthorized use or reproduction of The Daily Star content for commercial purposes is strictly prohibited and constitutes copyright infringement liable to legal action.